QUOTE= I am happy to use them myself, but the fact remains that they are no more definitive than OPA, NPA or LMA.
Is that true?
OPA and NPAs are definitely not definitive airways as they don't project from gastric regurgitation and aspiration therefore I-gels are more definitive.
I-gels are routinely used in theatres and pre-hospital and that's pretty definitive for me..
When would you take out an I-gel to intubate, long term ventilation with IPPV, I don't know?
Your pre-hospital and have a casualty with an I-gel insitu, taped and fixed, so you now decide to remove it, brave man, intubated and get your definitive airway.
Would I, probably not, please tell me I should and why.
I think the word definitive means not needed to be replaced and safe, does the I-gel qualify?
I'm trained in intubation, and thankfully never needed it pre-hospital, always carry the kit. Could I stand up in count and justify my use of an I-gel; from the PHEC course and the reading of the articles I'm sure I can, and that's good enough for me.
My airway kit will now consist of: OPA, NPA, I-gels full stop.
I think this is a great piece of kit, minimal training required with maximum life saving effect.
Thanks for the great debate, exactly why I posted, to let more of our colleagues here and use this great device.